Child Welfare in the Storm: What Happens to Vulnerable Families after a Disaster?

photo by ChairWomanMay

The day after Hurricane Sandy blew through the eastern seaboard, a social worker in Manhattan was frantic to track down a little girl on Long Island. The child is 2 years old and lives with her foster mother in a neighborhood that had been slammed by the storm. She had a tracheotomy when she was a baby, and needs a feeding tube to eat and an oxygen machine to breath. No one knew whether the family had been evacuated or where they were.

When the social worker finally reached the foster mother, it turned out she was at home, without heat or electricity. She’d been trekking to a nearby hospital to keep the girl’s medical equipment battery pack charged. “It wasn’t sustainable,” says Arlene Goldsmith, executive director of the child’s foster care agency, New Alternatives for Children. “But we hated the idea of separating her from the foster mother. That’s the last thing you want.” Instead, the agency—which had sent its fleet of seven vans to Connecticut to fill up on gas—was able to get hold of a generator. Once she had power, the foster mother also took in the girl’s brother, who’d been made homeless by the storm.

Even in normal times, child welfare is largely a system of crisis management: The city pays social service agencies not only to find foster homes for kids, but to provide services that prevent families from falling apart, working with parents before they come at risk of losing their children.

After Hurricane Sandy, which spawned many thousands of crises, child welfare workers became first responders, finding the families on their rolls and making sure kids were okay. New Alternatives for Children, which serves kids with serious medical needs, sent social workers and nurses to families’ homes, carrying long underwear and sleeping bags. “Our kids can’t get cold,” says Goldsmith.

Other agencies used city vans or sent caseworkers on foot to check on children considered to be at high risk. Good Shepherd Services, a foster care and preventive services agency that covers much of the Red Hook neighborhood in Brooklyn, turned one of its buildings into a distribution center for food and clothing donations. “Something like this shows how important it is that organizations are in communities, with infrastructure and staff,” says Michelle Yanche, an assistant executive director at Good Shepherd. “It’s a phenomenal example of how that infrastructure can be used to support communities in an emergency and stabilize people in a crisis.”

Natural disasters don’t discriminate. Sandy trashed million-dollar homes in Belmar, New Jersey  just as thoroughly as public housing in Far Rockaway. But the aftermath exacerbates the disparities that exist before the storm arrives. The people who end up most desperate and stay that way longest are usually those closest to crisis in the first place: Senior citizens who get trapped in their apartments after the elevators stop working in their buildings. Poor families with dependent kids who have nowhere to go but a shelter.

Last week—12 days after the storm—homebound residents in Red Hook Houses, a 30-building public housing development, were still dependent on meals and medication delivered by volunteers twice a day. A 7-year-old girl opened the door to the apartment where she lives there with her grandmother, whose electric wheelchair hadn’t worked since the power went out. Neighbors had been walking the girl to school in the morning. After dark, she bolted the locks and stayed inside. Without lights in the hallways, rumors were spreading through the building about attacks and home invasions. Several residents had heard that a 12-year-old girl was raped in a stairwell.

Many volunteers, who’ve been headquartered in Red Hook since the day after the storm, say they feel like they’re helping people who’ve been abandoned by the city. In addition to meal deliveries, they’ve set up a medical clinic, brought in lawyers to help with aid applications and kept track of residents who need ice to keep insulin cold. Last week, they installed solar powered lights in public housing hallways, days before the city managed to install freestanding streetlights on sidewalks. Their work has been coordinated largely by the Red Hook Initiative, a youth empowerment organization, and the all-volunteer group Occupy Sandy.

“People who were neglected before are neglected now. It’s not surprising,” said Hagar Aviram, a resident of Bed Stuy who’d spent the day coordinating a food distribution kitchen in Red Hook. “I heard the mayor was organizing a cleanup in Central Park, when old people here are still stuck in their rooms. It’s like ‘What are you doing? Where are you?’”

Yesterday, two weeks after the storm, Mayor Bloomberg set up recovery centers in some of the city’s most damaged neighborhoods, where storm victims can get ‘one-stop’ help with financial assistance applications and emergency services.

Even after the debris is cleared and the power comes back, the city’s storm crisis will almost surely spill into its housing crisis, which existed long before Sandy came. The number of children and families in city-run homeless shelters has been at a record high for more than a year. The city continues to operate five emergency shelters for storm evacuees, but nobody has a good estimate on the number of families who will become homeless long-term.

All of which raises another set of child welfare implications: While homelessness, on its own, is not a legal justification for removing families’ children and putting them in foster care, it often leads to chaos and instability, which put families at greater risk. “The reality is that when families are in crisis and when their housing becomes precarious, it does trigger more [child protective] cases,” says Yanche of Good Shepherd Services.

“When families are in the shelters they’re more subject to ACS scrutiny and to public scrutiny in general,” says Mike Arsham, executive director of the Child Welfare Organizing Project, a self-help and advocacy organization for parents with kids in the foster care system. “Things that would not normally be considered risk factors can get you in trouble. You aren’t allowed to leave older children alone, even momentarily. Or if you have a loud argument, it ups the ante for child-protective-involved families,” Arsham says.

Administration for Children’s Services Commissioner Ronald Richter says the city is committed to avoiding an increase in child removals. “I’m hopeful that doesn’t happen,” he says. “Our goal is never to remove a child, but to connect families to the services they need. We certainly don’t want to see children who’ve experienced Sandy experience the trauma of removal.”

Richter says the city’s preventive services system has the capacity to provide help to families who’ve been destabilized by the storm. The challenge will be to target services to the areas that have been the most badly hurt. “These kids have already been through trauma and displacement,” says Richter. “Our job is to get them the help they need to recover.”

12 Responses to Child Welfare in the Storm: What Happens to Vulnerable Families after a Disaster?

  1. chaturbate hack July 29, 2014 at 8:36 pm #

    Hi, I would like to subscribe for this website to obtain most recent updates, thus where
    can i do it please assist.

  2. benefits of sunbeds July 28, 2014 at 8:38 pm #

    I used to be able to find good information from your
    articles.

  3. free cam live July 28, 2014 at 2:31 am #

    When I initially commented I clicked the “Notify me when new comments are added” checkbox and
    now each time a comment is added I get four e-mails with the same comment.
    Is there any way you can remove me from that service? Thanks!

  4. Pentair Legend Back-Up Valve LLE10 July 27, 2014 at 6:04 am #

    Usually I don’t learn article on blogs, however I wish to say that this
    write-up very forced me to try and do so!

    Your writing style has been surprised me. Thank you, quite nice post.

  5. professional liability insurance July 26, 2014 at 9:30 am #

    Hi, I think your site might be having browser compatibility issues.
    When I look at your blog in Firefox, it looks fine but when opening in Internet Explorer, it has some overlapping.
    I just wanted to give you a quick heads up!
    Other then that, terrific blog!

  6. Lil Alchemist Cheat July 20, 2014 at 10:00 am #

    Get up and save the world and yourself through direct involvement
    in world affairs or through your financial and moral support.
    I must obviously be ready for a new challenge as I
    am talking in these terms

  7. paraben free fake tan July 16, 2014 at 6:26 am #

    Then, you only need to exfoliate again once you see patches or you are beyond getting touched up.

    You can get positive results of golden brown color
    with the help these spray tanning products. Immediately after a spray tan you shouldn’t wear anything tight
    to your skin. Spray tanning booths are safe for use
    on occasion with the proper precautions regarding covering the eyes, lips, mucous membranes and access to internal orifices.
    When starting your own spray tanning business it is so important to have the
    good quality equipment suitable to the type of business you want to operate.

    Gels and Mousses are again ideal for Normal, Oily and combination skin, but not for dry skin as they often don’t
    have enough moisture in them to hydrate the skin as they develop.
    This type of tanning has been developed in response to the dangers of natural sun tanning.
    This will make you look as though you have more cellular health again and as though your
    cells are better protected from UV rays. The only ones that
    have something to hide are the ones who have negative feedback, usually
    when I see these I just pass on by. So if you’re using
    a manual system here are a few quality guidelines to follow.

  8. guaranteed car finance liverpool July 11, 2014 at 1:26 am #

    Every weekend i used to go to see this website, for
    the reason that i want enjoyment, for the reason that this this web page conations genuinely fastidious funny information too.

  9. spray tanning information July 8, 2014 at 4:30 pm #

    With practice, the consumer can secure a natural looking tan quickly; some can complete the home spraying in just 10
    minutes. Let it sit for at least five minutes and then wash the streaks away.

    The chief component of Spray tan is known as DHA which plays a significant role in  protecting one’s skin from harmful UV rays.

    One of the benefits of purchasing a self tanning lotion that has a bronzer included is
    that you can purchase a lotion that works for your complexion. Particularly alcohol content is
    not used in the spray tanning products. You should also take
    into awareness your natural skin tone in choosing your fake tan product.

    Spray tans fall into two basic categories: do-it-yourself products available from stores.
    It’s a fact of the profession: slips and falls are
    common when dealing with spray tan products and a certified
    instructor will already have been schooled in techniques so this doesn’t happen.
    Cost runs from $15-$35 and some businesses offer reduced rates via package pricing.
    s little you can do unless your travel insurance policy covers a full refund of the costs and if it does then excellent,
    book yourself a last minute deal straight away and use the extra cash to treat yourself
    to an upgrade.

  10. Connie Hayek November 16, 2012 at 5:56 pm #

    Child welfare workers and social workers are often first responders in the event of a disaster. And yet, they rarely are regarded with the same level of respect as other first responders and public service employees. I recently noticed a sign in a store proudly stating that they gave discounts to military, first responders (fire fighters and police officers), and teachers for their service. I asked the store manager about this and pointed out the fact that social workers were not included. She advised me that it was a ‘corporate decision’.
    I have worked in child welfare for two decades. When a plane crashed in my community (killing over 100 people), myself and my colleagues were there within minutes to assist. When my home state experienced major flooding, we were there to assist with clean-up, help families find housing and address basic needs. When a tornado wiped out blocks in near my former high school, social workers were there to hand out food, supplies, assist with housing clean-up.
    Despite this commitment to community service, social workers and child welfare workers rarely are acknowledged for their service. This is evident in compensation and retirement packages, in ‘perks’ such as that offered by the store mentioned previously, and in general attitude towards the profession.

  11. Matt malina November 14, 2012 at 10:31 pm #

    Do the Red Hook houses not have power?

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Nov 27: News Articles Relating to Child Abuse & Neglect | MiPSAC - November 28, 2012

    [...] Nov 14, Child Welfare Watch: The day after Hurricane Sandy blew through the eastern seaboard, a social worker in Manhattan was frantic to track down a little girl on Long Island. The child is 2 years old and lives with her foster mother in a neighborhood that had been slammed by the storm. She had a tracheotomy when she was a baby, and needs a feeding tube to eat and an oxygen machine to breath. No one knew whether the family had been evacuated or where they were. Article also looks at several other types of issues likely to come up as a result of an overwhelming natural disaster. Increased workload and increased likelihood of PS reports when families are living in shelters and the like. Link to Article [...]

Leave a Reply