Case Closed: Thousands More Teens Are Now Diverted From Juvenile Court

Michael Tam via Creative Commons Flickr

Each year, more than 10,000 teens aged 15 and  younger are arrested by police. They begin their journey into the criminal justice system with a visit to an intake  officer at the Department of Probation. Increasingly, the trip stops there. In a remarkable turnaround, the probation  department has become an off-ramp for thousands of teens each year, diverting them away from court, and into short term community programs.

The number of teens aged 15 and under whose cases have been “adjusted” and closed by the probation department increased 47 percent between 2009 and last year, and has more than doubled since 2006. In 2011, 4,564 teens under age 16 arrested in New York City—38 percent of the total—had their cases closed through adjustment, up from 3,107 two years earlier. Today, the city funds nearly 30 community-based adjustment programs, serving just over 800 young
people as of June.

The terms of an adjustment can include restitution for victims and the completion of one of these special programs, which involve community service or other projects. Adjustment periods typically last 60 days, though they can be extended to four months with a judge’s approval. If a young person meets the terms, he or she walks away from the case with no need to go deeper into the justice system.

And that’s exactly the point: Especially for low-level offenders, explains Deputy Commissioner of Probation Ana Bermudez, involvement with the justice system often does more harm than good. “There is significant research that youth outcomes actually deteriorate with court processing, particularly when you’re looking at low-risk youth,” she says. “You interfere with those supports that were making them low-risk in the first place.”

Studies indicate that young people who are arrested and taken to court—even a juvenile or family court—are somewhat more likely to increase, rather than decrease, problem behavior, compared to those who aren’t put through the system. One meta-analysis of 29 random-assignment studies, covering more than three decades of research, found that court system involvement not only failed to deter future criminal activity, but often increased its likelihood.

So far, the probation department says its adjustment programs are getting positive results. Ninety percent of diverted youth make it through their assigned program, say officials. Of those, 86 percent are not rearrested within the following six months, during which their cases are tracked.


In a room on the 11th floor of the Family Court building in Brooklyn, former graffiti artist Ralph “Tatu” Perez is struggling to connect with the students in his Paint Straight program. There are just four of them—all teenage boys who’ve recently been arrested for graffiti or vandalism.

Short and spry, Perez leans back in his chair. “Y’all know what karma is?” he asks.

All but the two youngest kids nod their heads. A 13- and 14-year-old, recently arrived from Yemen, they are struggling to understand the language.

“You see these scars?” Perez asks, pointing to his own face. “I did a lot of bad things. Ever notice my nose? See how part of it is missing? I was attacked by two pit bulls.”

The kids lean forward, peering at his nose. Perez nods. “They chewed my face up. I went into a coma because I lost so much blood. Here I was, living life, thinking I was okay, then out of nowhere come these dogs.” He rolls his chair closer to the thirteen-year-old, who is wide-eyed. “You see?”

“You still have the dog?” asks the boy, only partially understanding.

“No man.” Perez laughs. “It wasn’t my dogs.” Then he goes back to his point. “You do bad things, it’s going to come back to you and haunt you.”

Perez’s Paint Straight program is one of several new programs funded by the probation department to work with kids who get in trouble with the law. According to Perez, in the two years he’s been running his classes, only one participant out of 60 was subsequently rearrested.

The program runs in six-week sessions during which arrestees meet in small groups with Perez, who talks with them about vandalism laws, addictive and compulsive behavior, and respecting their communities. He also gives them some art history, starting, he says, with how the human urge to draw on walls has existed “for as long as man stood up straight.” The goal is to teach respect for laws and community while still encouraging kids to express themselves artistically.

At the start of the first class, Perez checks in with the kids. He asks a 15-year-old about his involvement in gangs, but the youth shakes his head and says he is no longer involved.

Perez is pleased. “You left the gang? Why?”

The boy shrugs. “Because my girl.”

Perez nods. “That’s good. My mother says always listen to the women.”

The 13-year-old clicks his pen on and off, smiling brightly when Perez scowls at him. It’s hard to gauge how the class is being received by its participants. The two youngest boys—the Yemeni immigrants—are clearly having trouble following what’s going on. Perez says the boys weren’t familiar enough with U.S. customs to know that what they were doing was a crime. The younger of the two smiles winningly at everyone. The older one sits beside him, politely alert, but clearly left out of the conversation.

Another boy, the oldest in the group, is visibly frustrated to be there. He leans back in his chair, sullen, and sighs angrily when Perez questions him.

“This is stupid,” he says during a break. “How are you gonna tell us that graffiti is bad and then turn around and tell us how to do graffiti?”


Administrators at the Department of Probation set the goal of increasing adjustment rates several years ago as one more step in their work to keep kids at home rather than sending them to juvenile lockups. So far, the changes have been achieved not through a legal overhaul of the department, but rather through a series of small yet significant tweaks to procedural policy. Officials are giving probation staff more training on intake procedures, and teaching them to tailor their recommendations to the risk level that the youth presents.

After a young person’s arrest, a probation officer reviews the charges and talks to the people involved to try to get a sense of the severity of the situation, the youth’s home and school life, and any other relevant factors. Probation officers use a tool known as an RAI, or Risk Assessment Instrument, to evaluate the risk of allowing the youth to leave rather than placing them in detention.

Bermudez says that some kids deemed low-risk by the RAI are still sent to detention for what she characterizes as “system barriers”—situations where there’s no other safe and supervised place for a young person to go—but the goal is to keep as many low-risk youth as possible out of institutions. In 2011, the department adjusted 68 percent of youth deemed low-risk on the RAI.

In order for an intake officer to refer a young person for adjustment, probation officials must get the consent of  the victim of the offense. Bermudez says the department has sought to increase the willingness of common complainants, beginning with major department stores like Macy’s and H&M, which now consent to adjustment for young people who’ve been arrested for stealing merchandise as long as they complete the department’s online anti-shoplifting program. Between January and July of 2011, shoplifting offenses accounted for a full 16 percent of all youth arrests, officials say.

Other changes have been achieved simply by retraining intake officers, says Bermudez. In the past, if a young person already on probation was arrested on a new charge, officers automatically denied adjustment. Now however, if there is no public safety threat, staff are instructed to consider whether the underlying issues causing the young person’s behavior are already being addressed through their probation. If appropriate, probation can continue or enhance those services, rather than send the youth to court.

Unofficial policy also used to dictate that if a complainant couldn’t be reached by 3 p.m. on the day of an arrest, a young person could not be adjusted. Now, officers are instructed to wait at least 24 hours before making their decision.Delores Hunter, a supervising probation officer in the Bronx Family Court Intake Services Unit, says that while initially there were some reservations among intake staff, most of her colleagues now believe the changes are for the better. “It is refreshing to be able to stand up and say that we, the Department of Probation, are trying to offer children an opportunity to stay out of the system, and really mean it,” says Hunter. She maintains that parents, too, seem happier with the new methods. “We often meet parents who are either frustrated with their child for being arrested, or frustrated with a system that they feel arrested their child for no reason. But when they hear that we empathize with them and are able, when appropriate, to offer them adjustment services that will allow their child to get the help they need with minimal disruption, the parents leave more grateful than angry.”


At Paint Straight, the class is almost over. Soon Perez will  tell the kids he’s taking them for pizza down the block, as he does at the end of every class. They’ll gather up backpacks  and jackets and Perez will remind them to be on time next Tuesday. “If you don’t come next week, everyone takes a turn  throwing their schoolbooks at you,” he jokes.

Perez has talked to the kids for over an hour about graffiti, crime and community, and asked them about their families, their relationships, and their plans. An hour or so into the class, another young person joined the group–a former Paint Straight student, now returned as a mentor to others in the program.

But for now, Perez is still working to imprint the lessons he learned from his own life. Long ago, in the 1980s and early 90s, his DROID graffiti tag was notorious, peppered across the city. He says he long since decided that tagging and vandalism are not the way to make it as an artist, or in life.

“When you do good, it comes back to you,” he says to the teens, building on the karma theme.

He looks intently at each of the kids, one by one. “That’s what I believe. Maybe it’s God, maybe Allah, maybe the universe. When you do good, good things come back to you.”


44 Responses to Case Closed: Thousands More Teens Are Now Diverted From Juvenile Court

  1. absss November 15, 2016 at 8:33 am #

    This is just an informative article for all the people.In my point of view the crime activities in children’s mind is increased day by day. The solution is to provide more education and seminars to the children in school days.

  2. Homeopathy doctor in calicut November 14, 2016 at 9:53 am #

    This is an informative article.Doing crime in childhood is a series problem.We should want to promote education.Students are the backbone of a nation.Teenagers crime is increasing in today’s world.Drugs, alcohols lead them in to crime.

  3. Blog Review February 18, 2016 at 6:52 am #

    Can I just say what a comfort to find someone that truly
    understands what they’re discussing on the internet. You actually
    understand how to bring a problem to light and make it important.
    More people should check this out and understand this side of the
    story. I was surprised you’re not more popular since you definitely possess the gift.

  4. Bog Review January 31, 2016 at 1:20 pm #

    It is really a great and useful piece of info. I
    am happy that you simply shared this useful info with us.
    Please keep us up to date like this. Thanks for sharing.

  5. my website December 8, 2015 at 6:23 am #

    Hi there, everything is going sound here and ofcourse every one
    is sharing data, that’s really excellent, keep up writing.

  6. What is dandruff October 4, 2015 at 12:36 pm #

    I cannot beelive so manny teenagers are getting arrested theese days.. I hope government will provide some scholarships to help teenagers get off the stress and have money and education..

  7. Don’t risk the life of your computer in hands of novice technicians.
    In a large office a single use photocopier is necessary,
    particularly if you do multiple copies or you need to copy documents
    with many pages. The process of transmission of data all over the network, is
    carried out by a hardware, known as the media.

  8. Gazza April 30, 2015 at 11:59 pm #

    There is nothing more useful than good information in this day and age, after all we do live in the information age. Thanks for the info, it is very useful.

  9. sex appeal February 23, 2015 at 11:10 am #

    Yοu made some decent points there. I checked on the
    web fοr adԀitional information about the issue and fοund most people աill goo
    аlong with your views on this site.

  10. cirrus casino instant play December 12, 2014 at 12:29 am #

    Fine way of telling, and pleasant paragraph to take information about my presentation focus, which i am
    going to convey in academy.

  11. best shampoo for thinning hair and dandruff November 11, 2014 at 10:55 am #

    Theѕе hair fibers аrе superb fοr guys or females ѡhߋ wɑnt to swiftly аnd usually disgguise thе aƿpear ߋf thinning hair, cover plɑceѕ precisely ѕpecifically
    ѕpecifically ѕpecifically precisely еxactly
    wɦere the scalp ѕhows ƅy implies oof ߋr hide modest bald spots.

  12. California Colleges & Schools November 3, 2014 at 2:13 am #

    I like this website so much, saved to fav. “To hold a pen is to be at war.” by Francois Marie Arouet Voltaire.

  13. princess prom dress October 30, 2014 at 2:47 am #

    I like this website so much, saved to fav. “To hold a pen is to be at war.” by Francois Marie Arouet Voltaire.

  14. hair loss pills for women September 28, 2014 at 3:35 am #

    Wonderful beat ! I wish to apprentice while you amend your web site, how could i subscribe
    for a blog website? The account helped me a
    acceptable deal. I had been tiny bit acquainted of this
    your broadcast provided bright clear concept

  15. pink bandage dress french connection September 26, 2014 at 12:57 pm #

    In the past A-list celebrities like Courtney Cox, Jennifer
    Anniston, Eva Longoria, Andi Mc – Dowell, Liz Hurley and even Katherine Hepburn have
    all had their images and persona associated with an international skin care brand – with big bucks in advertising it.

    The more refined they are, the more money you need to shell out.
    Within the Wet Seal online store, you’ll find jeans, tops, graphic tees, sweaters, bottoms, dresses, active wear,
    outerwear, shoes, accessories, and intimates.

  16. crimsonchilla September 25, 2014 at 7:28 pm #

    The mess and the stink were not worth the trouble or the savings.
    Not once did we take into consideration the cost of these dragons.
    re one of those weird pets that only the strange
    and lonely have, aren.

  17. free online coupon codes September 25, 2014 at 3:41 am #

    Nice post. I was checking continuously this blog and I’m impressed!
    Very helpful info specially the ultimate section :) I handle such information much.
    I used to be seeking this particular info for
    a long time. Thanks and good luck.

  18. dunnage board September 24, 2014 at 10:33 pm #

    She has a charm that is slightly reminiscent of the childhood favourite Rosie and Jim’s Ragdoll, with a modernized interior to suit the 21st century traveller.

    After users select their avatar they’re transported into their apartment.
    The exception to this rule is when fishing structure, there will always be a calm spot behind
    structure that cat fish rest in and it will be natural for
    your bait to settle in this area.

  19. capsules September 23, 2014 at 3:03 pm #

    What can you do this week to support үour healthy efforts.
    ҬҺere іs a waay for ʏou tօ slim dοwn and start lοoking goօd.
    We кnoա frߋm ߋur investigations that oveг 90% of homе based busiuness owners fail.

  20. self-storage companies publicly traded September 19, 2014 at 9:50 pm #

    You get a companion and a friend you can actually rely on in times of trouble.
    Video Production improved presented impressing are sure to appeal
    video companies’ middle and old, large and small, traditional in a
    valuable and meaningful subject. Professional removal agencies of Noida address this problem.
    However, if they are susceptible, then try to get a feel for how
    the client thinks that the contractor has performed – even if he or she makes some criticisms then finish by
    asking what good points the contractor has. Mission Viejo homeowners can enjoy the many companies that will sometimes even offer a free
    estimate, and sometimes may have a referral discount as well.
    Large open space in the back of the truck leaves plenty
    of space for objects to fall out of place and get beat against each other,
    but there’s a simple solution to this problem, and it is to set the cargo
    bar of bars around the loading area of the vehicle in order to
    hold items in place. As we all knows that engine is a powerful machine infect we can say that our vehicle is nothing without engine so engine play an important role in our vehicle.
    Systems Administrator career opportunities along with technology Jobs
    and career are admirable for well-known image in the field of
    business. Other than working with all these
    made to order lanyards with regards to marketing, they can be made
    use of by lots of providers so that you can discern its team people.
    Now this idea was extended with the time and come in face of banking system.

  21. spray tanning kits September 18, 2014 at 9:45 pm #

    Fortunately for women, the lower back ages very well, so they should
    have no problems over the years with their tattoo.
    You also have to be at ease in your dress, able to glide
    down the aisle in it & look comfortable all day long.

    Actually, once you get used to working with these tools, you’ll probably wonder how you ever lived without them.

  22. fiberglass coleman marine coolers September 17, 2014 at 1:45 am #

    After a quick lunch and a brief nap back at the mobile home, we resumed fishing about three o’clock and fished all the way
    until dark. Given a choice, our primates will eat nothing but bananas.
    If you are a foreigner unlikely to return if allowed to leave,
    you will not be able to post a bond.

  23. Laser Hair Therapy Before and After September 9, 2014 at 7:30 am #

    Even frequent blow-drying at extreme heat or brushing obsessively can cause your hair to become extremely fragile causing it to break and fall out.
    When too much pressure is put on the hair over time
    it can speed up the hair shedding process, resulting in the loss of hairs already in the telogen phase.

    We live in a climate that gets hot and humid and there are many activities to choose

  24. bait ice cream freezer for sale September 6, 2014 at 10:08 pm #

    You don’t want to linger until the last minute to make your plan so I would recommend reading the waterway guidebook
    in advance. Nowadays, these super coolers are used for both commercial and domestic purpose.
    Bait casting are multiplying reels, with the
    spool mounted above the rod.

  25. Sophia September 6, 2014 at 11:11 am #

    I’ve been exploring for a little for any high-quality articles or blog posts in this
    sort of area . Exploring in Yahoo I at last stumbled upon this
    website. Studying this information So i am satisfied to show that I have a very just right uncanny feeling I came upon exactly what I needed.
    I so much surely will make certain to don?t put out of your mind this website and give it a
    glance regularly.

  26. cell phone spy expert August 31, 2014 at 1:53 am #

    What’s up, its ice post on thee topic of media print, we all know media is a enormous source of information.

  27. cell phone spy on android August 30, 2014 at 3:35 pm #

    Your style is so unique in comparison to other people I have read stuff from.
    I appreciate you for posting when you have the opportunity, Guess I’ll
    just book mark this site.

  28. Hi there! This is my first comment here so I
    just wanted to give a quick shout out and say I genuinely ejjoy reading your posts.
    Caan you suggest any other blogs/websites/forums that
    go over the same topics? Thanks!

  29. Tiffani August 29, 2014 at 10:29 pm #

    I’m not that much of a online reader to bee honest but your blogs really nice, keep iit up!
    I’ll go aheadd and bookmark your site tto come back down the road.

    All the best

  30. yeti fiberglass igloo marine coolers August 28, 2014 at 10:02 pm #

    It is defined as the lowering of the core body temperature.

    Nowadays, these super coolers are used for both commercial and domestic purpose.
    Another important application of second law of thermodynamics is
    found in refrigerators and heat pumps, which are based on the principle of reversed Carnot cycle or reversed Carnot theorem.

  31. Creditcard zonder BKR toetsing aanvragen August 25, 2014 at 6:45 pm #

    Get your First Millennium Platinum Card almost right away.
    If you want to have more options for credit cards,
    it is important that you work on improving your credit history and these cards will not help you with that.
    by which you can practically name anything as a reward to the credit card concierge, and he
    or she will tell you then how many rewards points you need.

  32. sun cream with fake tan August 17, 2014 at 8:53 pm #

    Dark sunsation self tanning lotion has botanical extracts, which improve the quality
    of your skin while offering you a dark natural looking tan. Since 10% of California’s budget goes to pay for its prison system, the idea is that AB 109 will free up billions in the state budget.
    There is no reason to be self-conscious about your body in front of the woman,
    or man, who is tanning you.

  33. hcg weight loss maximizers July 24, 2014 at 1:04 pm #

    The elimination of phase 1, the binging phase and
    the change to a 800 calorie a day diet are the
    two most important changes in the New HCG Diet for 2012.
    All the nutrition is in the skin while the middle is pretty much all unnecessary sugar.

    That’s Fit goes on to explain the diet featured on the stars’ page, saiyng: “The HCG drops that Farley promotes on her website can reportedly burn 3,500 to 4,000 calories of stored fat a day, providing you follow the strict HCG Diet — consisting of just 500 calories a day. Most of the people careful about their regular meal but they are very slapdash about their favorite food. Be sure to follow these HCG diet tips, and your frustration will be at a minimum and your success at a maximum. Of if it’s simply a habit, like snacking in the evening because you’ve come to associate TV time with food, then realize that with perseverance, a habit can be changed over time. When aiming to achieve a wear part, use sand paper as well as rub the corners and edges with the cabinets. The quick answer to Mayuki is that her fruit has too many carbs. Or what about cutting the apple from the core leaving most of the sugar to be thrown away. There are safe ways to lose weight in shorter periods than would be possible by simply changing the diet and exercising more.

  34. Deski PCV July 23, 2014 at 12:01 am #

    I wanted to create you that very little remark to be able to say thanks yet again considering the magnificent knowledge you’ve shown on this website. This has been so pretty generous of people like you to offer extensively all that many of us could have distributed for an ebook to make some cash for themselves, most notably since you might have tried it if you desired. The tactics in addition served to become great way to fully grasp other people online have the identical passion like mine to learn good deal more with respect to this issue. Certainly there are some more pleasant times in the future for many who view your site.

  35. palmer cutler fake tan July 19, 2014 at 3:31 am #

    Another criteria to choose fake tan product is the skin sensitivity and the
    guarantee that product really is safe and
    works. If self tanner is applied sooner, the hair follicles may still be open and the self tan product will pool inside the hair follicles
    and cause tiny dark spots all over legs. In order to keep your tan from becoming too orange, use the tanner daily for 3 days in a row or until
    you achieve your desired color. glow and many find that using
    fake tanning products can give you that edge, that confidence and a
    feeling of beauty. Mechanisms such as Sun Laboratories Spray Tan Machine allows you to improve the tone of your skin without ever
    having to worry about the expense of over-priced beach resorts.

    You should also take into awareness your natural skin tone in choosing your
    fake tan product. Tanning products are not new, but a certainly gaining in popularity.
    If you have not an issue together with the tanning chemicals,
    you need to follow that salon but when there seemed to be a conflict, continue to look for the chemical balance that is
    ideal for your skin type. Checking your makeup drawer every so
    often is a good idea, to make sure makeup is not expired.
    Pregnancy and Hormonal Changes – If you are pregnant, your body
    is most likely undergoing a myriad hormonal changes that
    could seriously affect the effectiveness of your laser hair removal sessions.

  36. Archlord 2 Beta Download With Gameplay July 11, 2014 at 10:47 pm #

    It’s great that you are getting ideas from this article as well as from our argument made at this time.

  37. Every weekend i used to pay a quick visit this site, for the reason that i want enjoyment,
    as this this site conations really fastidious funny information too.

  38. Gods will be watching beta download July 10, 2014 at 4:07 pm #

    I was more than happy to find this website. I need
    to to thank you for ones time due to this wonderful read!!

    I definitely enjoyed every little bit of it and I have you saved as a favorite
    to see new things on your web site.

  39. John May 17, 2013 at 1:49 pm #


    I need to identify the study referred to in the paragraph below. Please post here.


    Studies indicate that young people who are arrested and taken to court—even a juvenile or family court—are somewhat more likely to increase, rather than decrease, problem behavior, compared to those who aren’t put through the system. One meta-analysis of 29 random-assignment studies, covering more than three decades of research, found that court system involvement not only failed to deter future criminal activity, but often increased its likelihood.

  40. unknown December 12, 2012 at 3:32 pm #

    An adjustment period for a respondent is 60 days, However, for the first month they see a Probation Officer once a week and for the second month they see a PO once every two weeks. In reality,they see a PO 6 times. Do the victims who agree to the adjustment rather than taking their case to court really know that the respondent has contact with a PO 6 times. What kind of services can be put into place in 6 visits?


  1. bity na sprzedaż - May 21, 2015

    bity na sprzedaż

    Hi check out this music producer

  2. kabiny prysznicowe piotrków - May 19, 2015

    lustra na wymiar piotrków

    See this lustra na wymiar for yourself.Glass furniture,building and much more in Piotrków Trybunalski

  3. lustra - May 7, 2015

    lustra na wymiar piotrków

    See this lustra na wymiar for yourself.Glass furniture,building and much more in Piotrków Trybunalski

  4. Brushes With the Law: Young New Yorkers and the Criminal Justice System | Child Welfare Watch - December 10, 2012

    […] The number of arrested teens aged 15 and under whose cases have been diverted from court—or adjusted—and closed by the city’s probation department increased 41 percent between 2009 and last year. This number has more than doubled since 2006.  (See “Case Closed.”) […]

Leave a Reply